The Originators of Quick & Easy Cooking!
"Easy as Pie" Recipes: 40 Chocolate Pie Recipes, Fruit Pie Recipes & More
Bonus: Get our newsletter & special offers for free. We will not share or sell your email address. View our Privacy Policy
Amish Molasses Oatmeal Pie
(18 Votes)
Share This Recipe
- SERVES
- 8
- COOK TIME
- 40 Min
This is one of our most requested Amish pies. It'll bake up as homey and wholesome as it would on an Amish farm, but our shortcut pie crust will allow you to enjoy Amish Molasses Oatmeal Pie even during a busy week.
What You'll Need
- 4 eggs, lightly beaten
- 1 cup molasses
- 3/4 cup milk
- 1 tablespoon melted butter
- 1 cup sugar
- 1 1/2 cups quick-cooking oatmeal
- 1/2 cup chopped walnuts
- 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
- 1/4 teaspoon salt
- 1 (9-inch) unbaked deep dish pie crust
What to Do
- Preheat oven to 350 degrees F.
- In a large bowl, combine all ingredients except pie crust; mix well then pour into pie crust.
- Bake 40 to 45 minutes, or untl center is set. Let cool 30 minutes.
- Serve pie warm, or refrigerate and serve when ready.
Note
We suggest topping this pie with whipped cream or vanilla ice cream.
Share This Recipe
Thanks for your comment. Don't forget to share!
mrspansy2005 4257612
Sep 28, 2017
This is just waaaaay too sweet. It made my teeth ache. Might try again with stevia baking blend and just a little molasses--like, a short pour. Also used old-fashioned rolled oats instead of quick-cooking. Nice texture that way.
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
mkbnewport 3612129
Mar 03, 2014
This pie tastes disgusting. The molasses flavor was so strong and I even used mild flavored molasses. I would not recommend this pie to anyone. I had to throw it away. Yuck.
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
mygrandaddypaul 2056073
Nov 23, 2013
have not made it yet
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
bluebird1021 8539343
Nov 20, 2013
I made the Amish Molasses Oatmeal pie.....very disappointed. The taste of molasses was WAY too strong. Will not be making again! I would rate it @2
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
naturalstyles 1098485
Nov 14, 2013
Hello. Can you make this with old fashioned rolled oats instead of quick cooking oatmeal? I don't purchase the quick-cooking type. I do like molasses, so this recipe sounds delicious. Thank you!
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
SylviaC
Jul 17, 2013
I have made a similar pie but we always used golden syrup (not pancake syrup) instead of molasses. In Canada the syrup is made by Rogers, can't help for US brands, sorry. It is always a big hit in my home. I will try it with molasses just to see but from reading the earlier comments I will be using Fancy molasses and hope for the best.
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
nchewn 9713373
Jun 23, 2013
I made the Buttermilk Pie. My Mom used to make it and it was wonderful. Mine was awful and I was very careful to follow directions. I did not use the crust. It was watery and with very little taste. I wondered if it needed Vanilla.
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
lsschmick 7124772
Dec 05, 2011
The Amish Molasses Oatmeal Pie sounds delicious, I will be making it soon,. I also have a recipe to share , it is Butter Milk Pie, I made it all the time for my mom& dad & my grandfather, ( who are not with us any more ), now I make it for myself , I cook it without the crust, You need 1 pie crust, brushed with egg, then mix 2c. buttermilk, 2 tbsp flour, 2 tbsp butter ( melted ), 2 eggs, 1c. sugar, 1/2 tsp nutmeg, mix well, pour into crust, bake at 375 , until a knife comes out clean ( about 45 min ), cool & serve !!
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
Chefsmom
Oct 11, 2012
I love buttermilk pie! The first time I made it,my family wasn't any too eager to try it, but once they did, that's all she wrote - they loved it. One year for my birthday, my younger daughter made a bunch of mini buttermilk pies, enough to spell out "Happy Birthday Mom." It's so cool.
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
jht
Nov 14, 2012
My husband and I were just talking about a Buttermilk Pie his mom used to make. We asked the relatives, but no one could remember it. Thanks!
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
janetkukuruda 6624414
Oct 25, 2011
Center is set when you insert a knife in middle and it comes out clean.
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
janetkukuruda 6624414
Oct 25, 2011
I was very disappointed...the molasses is too strong...it was horrible...a pile of whipped cream made it tolerable but I will not make this recipe again...next time I will use corn syrup and brown sugar. I love Oatmeal pie...just not with molasses...sorry Mr. Food! Love your site tho! : )
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
mrsmoore18018
Jun 22, 2013
There are several types of molasses. Many are defined by the color of the label. Gold label has a light molasses taste, as does King Syrup. Green label has a very strong molasses taste. You may have used green label and not cared for the strong taste. I prefer the green, but some of my family do not. My mom used to mix them half and half. It's just a preference.
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
mrsmoore18018
Jun 22, 2013
BTW--It makes me so angry that molasses has such a high price. The dark molasses fed to farm animals in the winter reflects the true low cost before bottling it. I have used the agricultural molasses and it tastes the same as Green Label.
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
gusj 5477006
Oct 04, 2011
what do you mean until center is set ?
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
cherokee00044 0245726
Jul 28, 2012
no-loonger googy in center
- REPLY
- WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
- REPORT ABUSE
Report Inappropriate Comment
Are you sure you would like to report this comment? It will be flagged for our moderators to take action.
Thank you for taking the time to improve the content on our site.
LATEST TV RECIPE & VIDEO
Lemon-Caper Fish Fillets 
Did you know fish is the ultimate fast food? We're not talking about the stuff you get at a drive thru. These sunny-tasting fish fillets cooks up in just 8 minutes! You read that right. Our Lemon-Capers Fish Fillets combine lemon juice and the tangy flavor of capers to add just the right amount of "wow" to this easy dinner recipe!
You May Also Like
|
|
