3-Layer Nanaimo Bars

I made the nanaimo bars after visitinf Ontario. They were not like the bars I had there. These are cloyingly sweet. Will not repeat

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

I am not seeing the ingredients for the filling or top layer.

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

Test Kitchen Team

May 30, 2018

Hi there. We had an update to our site that caused some of the ingredients to be cut off in longer recipes. The issue has been resolved and you can view the full recipe now. Enjoy!

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

I'm not seeing the ingredients for "Filling" or 'Crust".

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

Test Kitchen Team

May 30, 2018

Hi there. We had an update to our site that caused some of the ingredients to be cut off in longer recipes. The issue has been resolved and you can view the full recipe now. Enjoy!

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

made this recipe exactly as written it came out Fantastic!!! love the walnuts in it and did some research there are many many Canadian variations and Yes Canucks DO use walnuts we live close to the Canadian border

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

grannytina1 2729616

Aug 09, 2017

Need to add I have never heard of potato salad made with mashed potatoes always cubed potatoes but whatever floats your boat!

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

rac7431 2877525

Dec 26, 2018

You would be surprised at what I do to mashed potatoes. Bacon, scallions or red onions, sour cream, butter....if it tasts good I don't care what's in it or if it's mashed or cubed.

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

Well, whatever it's called, this looks good and reminds of a dessert my mother used to make. I'll have to make this and then give it a rating. Thanks for sharing.

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

wcmundy...no need to get hysterical. I'm from Nanaimo, and I see many variations on our Canuk style of food preparation. Even here in Nanaimo, there are taste and styling Variations. I get bothered that U.S. style potato salad (Mashed potato rather than cubed/diced) is different... but I just flip the page and move along, knowing that what I like is what I like!. The World runs on variation and adaptation, don't ya' know! Relax, not worth a heart attack.... it's only a Dessert item!

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

sandangel59 2547378

Jul 11, 2017

I'm just curious...where did you have mashed potatoes claiming to be potato salad? Perhaps it was overcooked and broke down in the mixing process or someone was sadly misinformed in calling it potato salad. I, as my mother and grandmothers, make mine with cubed, boiled potatoes and mayo and a variety of additions/spices (depends on what's on hand or my mood).

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

cooma40 7754235

Aug 30, 2017

rabblrouzer We make our potato salad with cubed potatoes here is the US LOL NOT mashed potatoes. whoever made them like that, certainly has their own style. Just had to respond )

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

Whatever this is - it is NOT a Nanaimo Bar. We Canadians - especially those of us on the West Coast - would NEVER make them like this. There should be Fry's Cocoa Powder in the crust layer, as well as chopped almonds (NOT walnuts). The crust should be CHOCOLATE-y - NOT blonde-ish. The centre should be made with Bird's Custard Powder - not Vanilla Pudding. Leaving one ingredient out, altogether - and substituting for two other ingredients that are completely different in taste and texture - make this recipe something completely OTHER than Nanaimo Bars. Fry's Cocoa Powder, and Bird's Custard Powder - can be found in almost ANY grocery store that has a half-decent baking section. So to say that these two items - along with chopped almonds - are "exotic" - is just silly. Even WalMart stocks BOTH those items. The custard centre is a little less likely to wobble and smoosh when you try to cut the top (chocolate) layer - the only layer in the above recipe that is correct. Its texture and taste is quite different from Vanilla Pudding (?!?). Ditto the almonds - which are somewhat crunchier, and far less acidic than walnuts. Not to mention the entirely missing Cocoa Powder. I'm sorry - but no matter how you look at it, rationalise it, whatever - this recipe is NOT Nanaimo Bars. And it's an insult to we Canadians to be falsely represented with it.

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

steinert 5714632

Sep 09, 2016

Copied from Wikipedia " Many varieties exist, consisting of different types of crumb, different flavours of icing (e.g., mint, peanut butter, coconut, mocha), and different types of chocolate."

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

Why were the two Canadian comment that challenged the veracity of this recipe removed ?!? This is NOT a "famous" Washington State recipe - this is a WORLD-renowned CANADIAN recipe from Nanaimo, BC. Do you think that be re-writing hitory - and changing the recipe - it will make it true ?!? The recipe you have posted above - is NOT the "Nanaimo Bar" recipe. AT ALL.

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

Test Kitchen Team

May 19, 2016

Hello! You are correct - these originate in Canada, as our recipe note states, but they are very popular in the states that border Canada, too. This is also not an exact duplicate of the original Nanaimo Bar. We simplify our recipes, so that any home cook can make them and still enjoy them. Although they may not be exactly the same as the Nanaimo Bars you grew up with, we think you'll still enjoy these as much as others have! We hope you'll give them a try. )

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

wcmundy 6493360

May 19, 2016

You are suggesting that the original recipe - which includes cocoa powder and almonds (rather than walnuts) in the base layer and Bird's Custard Powder in the middle layer - uses "exotic" items that a "home cook" would not be able to find at his/her grocery store ?!? Also - just because an item is "popular" in another country - that does NOT give that country the right to usurp or change a recipe - call it the same thing - and say it's a "Famous State Dessert" of said other country. Very disappointed in this. It now makes me question the veracity of ALL of the recipes as being authentic to the stated area . . . And the bottom line is that your recipe - whatEVER it could be called - is NOT a Nanaimo Bar.

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

wildwestpb

May 29, 2016

Fry's Cocoa Powder and Bird's Custard powder are not available everywhere. I have never seen it stocked in any of my local grocers. It is only available online for me. So yes, for some, these are exotic items that a home cook are not able to find in my local grocery store.

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

pattyharris1962 3547472

Feb 03, 2017

Hear, hear! In the US, in the Midwest, certainly never saw or heard of Fry's or Bird's. Pudding suggestion is what I would need. Sorry to see you felt culturally attacked, but variations of standard recipes just allow for individuality (and availability!), and don't diminish the original.

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

I love this recipe but I use banana pudding instead of vanilla, and dark chocolate for the topping. This makes it rich but sooo good.

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

I have made this for years, and the recipe I have calls for 1/4 c. cocoa in the bottom layer? It is better if you leave it a day in the refrigerator, it gives the sugars time to dissolve and flavor is way better.

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

wcmundy 6493360

May 17, 2016

You are right. The original recipe - from Nanaimo, BC (on Vancouver Island) - calls for 5 Tbsp of Fry's Cocoa Powder in the bottom layer. Also the finely chopped nuts should be almonds - not walnuts. And finally - the middle layer is a CUSTARD layer (Bird's) - not pudding.

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

Ladynightmare

May 29, 2017

You are an extremely rigid person who thinks the whole world has Fry's Bird's. You are mistaken very narrow minded. Have you never adapted a recipe to your liking....Sure you have. Foolish of you to act so insulted.

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

Enjoyed the creamest of the filling. Wanted to make it as soon as saw the recipe but did not have grahm cracker crumbs. Subsituted butter cracit was so good.ker crumbs and

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

really, really rich!! will soon be take-along fav!!!

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

Ok while I have not made this recipe yet I am giving it 5 STARS it is a very good recipe for Nanaimo bars and uses easy to get ingredients I just don't think its fair to put down t a recipe just because someone forgot to type in a pan size which pretty easy to judge by the amount of ingredients

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

whosyournana 9622226

Jun 16, 2015

8"X8" pan....

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

what size Baking dish?

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE

Test Kitchen Team

Jun 12, 2015

We apologize for the confusion. You will need an 8 x 8-inch baking dish for this recipe. We've updated the instructions to include this information. Thank you for your comment!

• REPLY
• WAS THIS HELPFUL? YesNo
• REPORT ABUSE